Opinion
SOUTH AFRICA IS SPENDING BILLIONS RESPONDING TO VIOLENCE
BUT ALMOST NOTHING IS BEING DONE TO PREVENT IT
Lesley Ann Van Selm
South Africa is living through a violence epidemic so deeply woven into daily life that many people no longer recognise its weight. We see the posters, the awareness campaigns, the public statements of commitment from leaders. Each year during the 16 Days of Activism, we speak of “raising our voices.” Yet for millions of women, children, families and communities, the remaining 349 days look painfully familiar.
Despite billions being spent on policing, crisis counselling, emergency medical care, shelters and public messaging, violence continues to rise. Gender-based violence (GBV) alone drains an estimated R28–R42 billion from the economy every year. Bullying in schools and workplaces continues to climb. Cyberbullying is increasing at twice the rate of in-person bullying. Femicide remains five times higher than the global average.
It is not that South Africa is doing nothing. It is that South Africa is doing the wrong things. We are responding — but we are not preventing.
THE COSTLY ILLUSION OF ACTION
For decades, the country has heavily relied on interventions that are visible, politically acceptable, and symbolically reassuring, such as advertising campaigns, emergency services, court processes, and post-incident disciplinary measures. While these responses are important—survivors depend on them, families rely on them, and institutions cannot function without them—they have one significant flaw: they only come into play after harm has already occurred.
Every day, more resources are poured into managing the consequences of violence instead of preventing it from escalating. This creates a system built on the assumption that violence is inevitable and that our role is merely to clean up the aftermath.
This is not only emotionally devastating — it is economically unsustainable.
WHAT REAL PREVENTION LOOKS LIKE
Prevention is quieter. It is local. It is relational. It occurs long before a case number is opened or a hospital bed is occupied. Often, it manifests as something seemingly simple, like community mediation. Not mediation in a boardroom. Not a bureaucratic process. Instead, ordinary people — trained in listening, de-escalation, and restorative methods — step into conflicts early, long before they escalate into crises.
Imagine ten trained mediators within a single community. They are neighbours, elders, youth leaders, teachers, and home-based carers — individuals who understand local dynamics and unspoken tensions. They work in teams of three, resolving disputes discreetly, respectfully, and effectively.
Examples include:
- A teen couple on the brink of violence
- Parents and children trapped in cycles of shouting
- Neighbours ready to retaliate after an insult
- Youth escalating online arguments into street fights
- Families strained by trauma, unemployment or disability
These mediators intervene early, at the point when harm can still be prevented. In a year, a team of mediators can handle approximately 45 cases per month, directly reaching over 1,000 people and influencing another 1,500 to 2,000 indirectly. They work to stabilise families, rebuild trust, defuse retaliation, and create environments where individuals feel heard rather than threatened.
The cost of running this entire intervention for a full year?
R150,000.
- Less than the cost of one SAPS billboard campaign.
- Less than one extensive GBV investigation.
- Less than the economic fallout of a single violent incident.
THE RIPPLE EFFECT OF PREVENTION
Every conflict touches far more than two people. A domestic dispute affects children who absorb fear, neighbours who feel unsafe, relatives who intervene, workplaces that experience the spillover, and community peace that becomes fragile.
When mediators prevent escalation, they support far more than one individual — they stabilise the entire circle around that person. A community with mediators is a community with pressure valves.
A community without them is a community waiting for the next explosion.
THE EVIDENCE SPEAKS — LOUDLY
This is not a theory. South Africa has one of the strongest global evidence bases for community mediation.
During the EU-funded Justice and Restoration Programme (JARP), mediators resolved 6,318 cases, achieving:
- 84% successful resolution
- 95–97% survivor satisfaction
- 87–97% offender accountability
- Zero retaliation in most mediated matters
- 88,438 indirect beneficiaries
These results were achieved in communities marked by unemployment, trauma and long-standing mistrust. Even after the programme ended, mediators continued working informally because communities valued them so deeply.
Today, Khulisa continues to see these outcomes — preventing violent retaliation in Alexandra, supporting disability-related GBV cases in Musina, stabilising teen relationships in Soweto, de-escalating school and neighbourhood conflict in Cape Town, and strengthening women’s safety networks in Rustenburg. Every mediated case is a life redirected. Every de-escalation is a tragedy avoided.
WHY PREVENTION PAYS FOR ITSELF: A HYPOTHETICAL EXAMPLE
To understand the economic power of prevention, imagine one severe GBV incident that escalates into police involvement, emergency medical care and a court process.
Typical costs:
- SAPS investigation: R6,500–R12,000
- Medical care: R4,000–R20,000
- Court and prosecution: R15,000–R35,000
- Counselling and trauma support: R3,000–R8,000
- Lost productivity: R5,000–R15,000
- Potential shelter placement: R2,000–R5,000
Total: R35,000–R95,000 for one case.
Now imagine a trained mediator steps in before the violence escalates. If mediation prevents even two such cases in a year, the savings exceed the total annual cost of running a 10-mediator team. In reality, mediators prevent dozens of crises each year. The return on investment is not simply high — it is staggering. South Africa cannot afford to keep responding to violence. We can only afford to start preventing it.
A NATIONAL PREVENTION STRATEGY IS NO LONGER OPTIONAL
The 16 Days of Activism raises awareness.
But mediation prevents harm every day of the year.
- Mediation is:
- Affordable
- Scalable
- Locally owned
- Evidence-based
- Trauma-informed
- Culturally rooted
- Proven to reduce violence across provinces
We already have the tools. We already have the evidence. We have thousands of mediators ready to be trained, supported and deployed. What we lack is national commitment. South Africa must stop treating violence as unavoidable. It is preventable, predictable and highly responsive to early intervention. If we are willing to invest in what actually works, we can shift the trajectory of a country exhausted by trauma and fear. Prevention is not a dream. It is already happening — quietly and consistently — in communities where mediators walk alongside families long before a crisis erupts.
It is time to listen to what the evidence is telling us: Responding to violence is expensive. Preventing it is transformational.
About us
Khulisa is a non-profit organization dedicated to driving social change through innovative and evidence-based programs. With over 28 years of experience, we work to build safer, healthier, and more inclusive communities by addressing systemic inequalities and empowering individuals. From restorative justice initiatives to community capacity-building projects, our mission is to create sustainable impact and provide vulnerable populations with the tools they need to thrive.
For more information, contact
Lesley Ann Van Selm | 082 601 2299 | lesleyann@khulisa.org.za | media@khulisa.org.za
